Community policing has been promoted as a key strategy for reducing crime and improving police-community relations. In Umuahia, Abia State, Nigeria, efforts to implement community policing have faced significant challenges, particularly with conventional law enforcement practices. This study investigates the effectiveness of community policing in reducing crime rates and enhancing police-community collaboration, identifying the barriers to successful implementation. The problem arises from the disconnect between community policing principles and actual police behavior, as well as mistrust and limited collaboration between law enforcement and community members. The objectives of the study were to assess the impact of community policing on crime reduction, evaluate its influence on police-community relations, and identify the challenges faced during implementation. An experiential research approach was employed, using in-depth interviews with selected participants to gather data on their perceptions and experiences with community policing in Umuahia. The findings reveal that while community policing has improved information sharing and intelligence gathering, its potential is hindered by resource constraints, resistance from conventional police officers, and a lack of genuine engagement with the community. Furthermore, mistrust and skepticism about the police’s intentions continue to undermine effective collaboration. Participants proposed several recommendations, including enhancing community engagement, strengthening oversight mechanisms, and implementing anti-corruption measures to improve accountability and transparency. The study concludes that addressing these challenges is essential to realizing the full benefits of community policing in Umuahia. Strengthening collaboration between police and community members, allocating adequate resources, and promoting ethical behavior among officers are key to ensuring the success of community policing initiatives.